Living in
America, you might think the majority of the products that you purchase would
be made in the United States, but the last presidential election indicated a
different conclusion.
Many of the speeches and debates centered around imported goods, especially
those from China, and the effect on the economy.
In
investigating the context on a national level, the Federal Reserve Bank of San
Francisco in their FRBSF Economic Letter provides stats of the following
data: Chinese goods account for 2.7%
of U.S. PCE [Personal consumption expenditures], about
one-quarter of the 11.5% foreign share. Of the 2.7% of U.S. consumer
purchases going to goods labeled “Made in China,” only 1.2%
actually represents China-produced content. If
we take into account imported intermediate goods, about 13.9%
of U.S. consumer spending is attributable to imports, including
1.9% imported from China.
(Hale and Hobijn)
The 2.7%
figure is a surprising since
the consumer encounters so many items from foreign countries, principally
China, in the discount stores.
Looking at the numbers of how many products are produced in China compared to
America, the U.S.A looks pretty good. It would appear that the manufacturing
goods of China really do not dramatically impact America, like we might expect. Before looking more into this, I
suspected that the results from sampling small ticket items in a discounted
store would show very different results.
Living in a small college town only gives
you a few stores to choose from when shopping for essentials. There are a
handful of major stores to shop at, like Wal-Mart, Big Lots, H.E.B., and Dollar
Tree, just to name a few. I need a few things for a family gathering, so I went
to Big Lots. It is a discount store, but compared to Walmart, the access is
much easier and parking is convenient.
My
expectations were proved correct by the fact that there were so few American
items and so many from other countries. In relation to the small number of
American-made products, I noticed that the store arrangement gave much more
attention to imported goods. For example, immediately on your left
when entering the store there is a large area of imported pottery, imported
art, and imported furniture often from the overflow of stores like Pier One,
whose items are almost always from other counties.
I
predicted when going into the store that items that were made in America were
going to be a little higher in price and harder to find.
I also was assuming that most of the items in Big Lots were going to be
made by a foreign country.
However, I was hoping that I would find a few more American-made products than
I did. Big
Lots does carry a few bigger ticket items such as furniture, but I did not
check those items because I would expect a store featuring furniture and
appliances, (such as Sears), to have some USA assembly component on most of the
items (similar to what I found with the pillows in Big Lots).
Actually,
the United States of America makes or grows a
variety of items that other countries cannot, will not, or cannot ship. The New York Times
reported that about thirty years ago, the United States produced eighty percent
of our country’s produce, now it is down to around sixty-five percent,
according to the Manufacturers Alliance/ MAPI, an industry trade group. The stamp Made in U.S.A. is most likely to
be printed on heavy equipment such as circuits that go inside other products,
toys, clothes, aircraft, missiles, and even space-related equipment. The Times continued
The United States sold more
than $200 billion worth of aircraft, missiles and
space-related equipment in 2007,
and $80 billion worth of autos
and auto parts. Deere,
best known for its bright green and yellow tractors, sold $16.5 billion worth of
farming equipment last year, much of it
to the rest of the world.
Then there are energy products
like gas turbines for power plants made by General
Electric, computer chips
from Intel and fighter jets from Lockheed Martin. Household
names like GE, General Motors, International
Business Machines, Boeing and
Despite
the fact that the United States seems to make more large equipment, the U.S.A still supplies
much of the processed foods that our country consumes. We also make a
good portion of products used for personal hygiene; for example, soap and
shampoo, as well as cleaning supplies and prescription drugs (The New YorkTimes).
While my purchase indicates
that Big Lots carries many more foreign products than American-made, the
overall picture presented by Hale and Hobijn does not present a threatening
trade balance. This may be due to sectors other than retailing,
such as raw materials, autos, or services. With many bulk or large ticket items being produced within
our borders, they appear to balance out the inexpensive products that are being
made in China and other foreign countries. However, the job market for
unskilled labor or low-tech products could definitely be impacted in the
current sluggish economy.
I think that discount stores carry more imported products than domestic products due to the price variance in their creation. Even the smallest manufactured parts are cheaper when imported, even with the cost of shipping, due to the high wages of American workers and the high cost and taxes to maintain a corporation here. That is why many people who chose to develop manufacturing plants do so in other countries. The labor is cheaper, utilities, buildings, and taxes are cheaper, and sending the products back into the United States is cheaper than having them produced here. Also, they can maintain a higher profit margin becuase the items that were so inexpensive to make in that foreign country can be sold in the U.S. for a pretty penny. I wouldn't imagine that anything made in the U.S. could be sold in a discount store. The revenue brought in by a domestic product sold in a discount shop would likely not even be enough to cover the cost it took to manufacture it here.
ReplyDeleteI believe there is a reason that so many products in the U.S. tend to not be produced by the U.S. The main reason if I had to guess is from outsourcing. When a company outsources a product to another country the production cost tends to be cheaper. Thats why domestic products are so high in price while that same product from over seas tends to be lower cost. Thus many companies today have started to outsource there products to overseas manufacturers.
ReplyDeletePeople seem to be drawn toward imported products. I think it has something to do at the psychological level. Also, I don't think we have reached an even balance of imported and exported goods.
ReplyDelete-Claire Real